From the YouTube Sick Teenager Files

Some questions about Christian Science's take on sickness in animals

From The Straight Dope

Interrobang!?
09-11-2005, 10:12 PM
Note: my understanding of Christian Science's take on sickness in humans is primarily based on conversations with a couple of friends who were raised in a CS home but long ago gave up practicing. If I'm wrong about any of my assumptions, it's my own damn fault.

OK, as I understand it (simplistically), Christian Scientists believe that people become sick because they're "under the belief" that they have an illness. Christian Science and prayer can cure illness when it helps people remember that they are spiritual beings, like God, rather than physical beings.

Basically, then, disease is a trick of the mind, or a tricking of the mind by the physical world.

Why, then, according to Christian Science, do animals get sick?

Are they, unlike human beings, imperfect creatures that are naturally prone to physical ailments? (A Cartesian division between humans and animals -- we are spiritual beings, animals aren't?)

Do they, in their way, believe in their own illness?

According to CS teachings, can prayer help cure animals? Is that an acceptable use of prayer?

Is there a tension between CS practice and taking your animal to the vet the same way there's (sometimes) a tension between CS practice and going to the doctor?

Is "veterinarian" a hunky-dory job for a devout Christian Scientist?
Duck Duck Goose
09-12-2005, 09:05 AM
Found this, (http://www.skepticreport.com/health/christianscience.htm) FWIW:

Although her writing was not clear on the subject, Mrs. Eddy apparently thought that domesticated animals got sick because of the incorrect beliefs of people: "You can even educate a healthy horse so far in physiology that he will take cold without his blanket, whereas the wild animal, left to his instincts, sniffs the wind with delight." (Science and Health, p. 179)
[shrug]

[bump from page 2]
Catalyst
09-12-2005, 10:05 AM
So ... domesticated animals get sick because they learn about illness from us? Hm, that's neat. What about wild animals? Do they see the domesticated animals dropping dead and decide it looks like fun? Maybe we're transmitting brainwaves full of fake ideas about diseases. Yeah, that might explain it.

Ugh, thinking like a loonie is making my head hurt.
Interrobang!?
09-12-2005, 12:31 PM
Interesting, DDG.

FWIW, my friends didn't know of any particular CS teachings about animal sickness, and their family always used a vet. But their mother wasn't exactly a hard-core believer, so I don't know that their behavior closely matched the CS ideal.
FlyingRamenMonster
09-12-2005, 12:34 PM
This is almost as good as breatharianism 8)

[sic]

Psych!

Sicker

Matthew, I'll see your sick and raise you sicker.

They Call Me The Hollywood Farmer

because that's what I call myself. And everyone I know is very polite, so they refrain from making up their own names for me.

Sick

Sick sick sick

I've always wanted to write "lorem ipsum"

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Ut nec turpis mi. Cras pharetra luctus sagittis. Cras auctor, quam sed hendrerit auctor, elit mauris convallis turpis, in lacinia magna dui id arcu. Maecenas iaculis risus sit amet urna vulputate pharetra luctus lorem commodo. Nulla a risus et lorem convallis aliquam et gravida tellus. Ut vestibulum dui ac nisl feugiat a dictum nisl tempus. In hendrerit rhoncus lobortis. Sed vitae nisi mauris, nec sagittis urna. Class aptent taciti sociosqu ad litora torquent per conubia nostra, per inceptos himenaeos. Vestibulum ante ipsum primis in faucibus orci luctus et ultrices posuere cubilia Curae; Cras sollicitudin risus ut lectus consequat eget dictum lectus aliquam. Aenean vitae arcu diam, eu blandit tellus. Sed sed sapien turpis, vel consequat ipsum. Nunc quis risus quam. Morbi faucibus massa eget sapien dignissim euismod. Ut nec metus sed libero vestibulum feugiat. Duis venenatis, ante vel blandit sagittis, urna ligula faucibus nisi, quis commodo mi quam vitae lacus. Aenean ornare ligula id arcu porta ac commodo erat suscipit. Etiam vel purus et odio sodales pharetra ut ac arcu. Nam elementum ullamcorper euismod.

Vestibulum fringilla metus vitae massa varius eget sollicitudin felis convallis. Sed commodo erat vitae purus porta placerat vitae quis nulla. Aliquam cursus tortor et elit dictum nec ullamcorper metus auctor. Sed pharetra pretium nunc, vestibulum viverra neque malesuada ut. Vestibulum at bibendum nisl. Donec porta tortor vel lacus tempor tempus. Etiam luctus euismod orci, nec sodales sapien ultrices non. Mauris vel turpis molestie dolor malesuada iaculis. Pellentesque habitant morbi tristique senectus et netus et malesuada fames ac turpis egestas. Sed libero dolor, mattis ac eleifend lobortis, gravida id elit. Donec massa arcu, semper ac dapibus sed, facilisis in nunc. Integer sem lectus, blandit ac sodales et, ullamcorper nec nisl. In hac habitasse platea dictumst.

Nullam quis convallis lacus. Morbi consequat, augue eu porttitor varius, lacus turpis gravida libero, sit amet congue justo sapien sit amet urna. Donec porta laoreet magna non eleifend. Donec rutrum luctus aliquam. Maecenas eget ullamcorper augue. Aliquam fringilla venenatis elit euismod sagittis. Nulla facilisi. Aliquam eu massa mi, non varius nisi. Curabitur non ante eu ligula elementum faucibus id vel eros. Etiam tristique neque ut massa laoreet sit amet rhoncus lacus facilisis. Aliquam justo lacus, vestibulum a fringilla a, sagittis vitae sem. Etiam rutrum tristique vulputate. Vivamus mollis lacinia nibh, sit amet pellentesque nisi dignissim at. Curabitur eget sapien congue nisl mollis tempor vitae ut magna. Fusce id felis est. Quisque sagittis orci eu turpis iaculis dignissim.

Curabitur turpis elit, vehicula vitae mollis vitae, vehicula id odio. Morbi sodales tincidunt purus, quis sollicitudin urna porttitor sed. Integer eleifend est sed elit aliquet quis mollis eros fringilla. Nam quis ligula justo. Donec in mi eu neque blandit viverra. Vivamus lobortis lorem ut enim venenatis sed consequat elit bibendum. Donec egestas tellus sed turpis condimentum elementum. Curabitur commodo gravida faucibus. Donec quis volutpat tellus. Fusce eget consectetur neque.

Nulla volutpat dolor sit amet nisl blandit pulvinar. Proin eget elit ipsum. Proin condimentum odio sit amet velit semper eget vestibulum justo consectetur. Nullam blandit ipsum vitae lacus vehicula sed imperdiet velit tristique. Cras ut leo pellentesque purus mollis luctus. Duis tristique tincidunt malesuada. Morbi neque elit, viverra ut lacinia nec, consectetur nec lorem. Cras eu porttitor nulla. Cras nisl lectus, tincidunt id egestas quis, auctor fermentum sem. Nunc vulputate dui id diam vulputate commodo. Pellentesque quis massa augue. Duis velit erat, ultricies at scelerisque id, volutpat et metus. Nulla id placerat dolor. Etiam egestas turpis aliquet nunc molestie dapibus venenatis turpis pretium. Mauris quis purus adipiscing metus convallis venenatis id eu odio. Fusce elit purus, luctus ac iaculis in, cursus at velit.